The Future of HSAs: A Vision for Integrated Health and Wealth Management

Doug Miles
Nov 09, 2024By Doug Miles

(EDITOR'S NOTE: This article was written prior to the November 5th national election, which resulted in single-party control over the White House, the Senate, and the House of Representatives. This shift in control will likely result in significant changes to HSA regulations. HealthyWealth will publish a special newsletter edition to drill down on expected changes to the HSA landscape after the mandated rewriting of significant portions of the federal tax code in 2025. Subscribe to the newsletter here.)

The Health Savings Account (HSA) market is at a pivotal juncture, poised for transformative growth and innovation. Traditional forecasts have long anticipated steady expansion, but they often miss a critical evolution reshaping the industry: the shift toward investment-focused, self-directed platforms that seamlessly integrate spending capabilities. This convergence of market expansion and platform evolution is more than a passing trend; it represents a fundamental redefinition of how individuals manage their health and finances.

Recent data underscores this significant shift. By 2026, total HSA cash deposits are projected to reach $111.7 billion, with investments soaring to $115.2 billion. Remarkably, the investment-to-deposit ratio is expected to exceed 100%, highlighting a decisive move toward investment-cen tric HSAs. Self-directed platforms are anticipated to capture 85% of the market share, signaling a transformative change in asset management and user preferences.


Table 1: HSA Market Growth Projections (2023-2026)

YearTotal Deposits (in billions)Total Investments (in billions)Investment Ratio (%)Self-Directed Platform Share (%)

2023

7646.46135
202484.365.77845
202597.885.48765
2026111.7115.210385

Forces Shaping the HSA Landscape
Three primary forces are propelling this revolution: demographic momentum, digital migration, and platform evolution.

Demographic Momentum
Millennials and Gen Z are instrumental in driving this shift. Millennials, entering their peak earning years with over a decade of HSA ownership, are eager to maximize their accounts' investment potential. Gen Z, as digital natives, exhibit higher early adoption rates of investment vehicles and prefer self-directed financial tools. Their combined engagement is creating a sustained growth wave for self-directed platforms.

Digital Migration
The digital era is fundamentally altering how consumers engage with financial products. Search trends reveal a growing interest in investment-focused HSAs, with terms like "HSA transfer" and "HSA investing" reaching peak popularity. Online communities, such as Reddit forums, are vibrant with discussions on optimizing HSAs through better investment options. Educational content on platforms like YouTube further empowers consumers to make informed decisions about their health finances.

Evolving Platform Feature Sets
We've seen a growing transfer of HSA funds directed toward Fidelity, the only true brokerage-based health savings account platform. Brokerage accounts have baked-in advantages over traditional HSA spending accounts and greater flexibility on incentives and investing features that the spending accounts cannot offer without significant transformation.

At HealthyWealth, we envision a new paradigm for HSAs—one that combines traditional spending functionalities with advanced investment features and innovative financial tools like Medical Margin Loans along with direct to consumer health-focused e-commerce. Our goal is to create a purpose-driven brokerage focused on health, longevity, and financing longer, healthier lives.

The Integrated HSA Model
The market is transitioning from a dichotomy of spending HSAs and investment-focused HSAs to an integrated model that offers the best of both worlds. This evolution is crucial for meeting the comprehensive needs of today's consumers.

HealthyWealth's Approach
Our platform is designed to provide a seamless experience that aligns with users' financial and health goals:

Comprehensive Investment Options: Access to a wide array of investment vehicles, tailored to individual objectives.
Spending Capabilities: Easy management of qualified medical expenses through traditional HSA functionalities.
Medical Margin Loans: Innovative financing that allows users to cover immediate healthcare costs without liquidating investments.
Health and Longevity Focus: Tools and e-commerce resources promoting wellness, preventive care, and long-term health planning.

This holistic approach ensures that individuals are not forced to choose between immediate healthcare needs and long-term financial growth.

Market Share Transformation
The shift toward integrated platforms is reflected in market share projections.

Table 2: Market Share Transformation


Current State (2024)Projected State (2026)
"Spending" focused HSA Platforms55% of assets15% of assets
Investing focused45% of assets85% of assets
Investing focused accounts35% of all accounts65% of all accounts


By 2026, investing-focused HSA platforms that also provide spending capabilities are expected to manage 85% of assets. This underscores the urgency for traditional providers to adapt and for new entrants to innovate.

Challenges for Traditional Providers
Traditional HSA providers face several hurdles:

Technological Limitations: Payment-based systems restrict the potential integration of advanced investment features.
Business Model Constraints: Reliance on deposit-related fees limits flexibility and innovation.
Customer Experience Gaps: Lack of robust investment options and subpar digital interfaces fail to meet modern expectations.

These challenges highlight the need for a new approach that aligns with consumer demands for integrated services.

Strategic Implications

The evolving landscape presents critical considerations for all market participants.

For HSA Providers

Embrace Integration: Develop platforms that offer both spending and investment capabilities.
Innovate Financial Tools: Introduce offerings like Medical Margin Loans to provide flexible financing.
Adopt a Purpose-Driven Model: Focus on promoting health, longevity, and the financing of healthier lives.

For Employers

Diversify HSA Options: Offer employees choices that cater to both immediate spending needs and long-term investment goals.
Evaluate Providers Holistically: Assess HSA platforms based on their ability to integrate spending, investment, and innovative financing.
Promote Wellness and Financial Health: Encourage the use of HSAs as tools for comprehensive health and financial planning.

For Account Holders

Seek Integrated Solutions: Choose platforms that do not force a trade-off between spending and investing.
Maximize HSA Potential: Leverage tools that allow for both immediate healthcare financing and long-term wealth accumulation.
Plan for Longevity: Use HSAs as a means to finance not just current health expenses but also future wellness and longevity goals.

The Road Ahead

The future of HSAs lies in platforms that recognize and respond to the interconnected nature of health and wealth. We anticipate several trends:

Standardization of Integration: Combined spending and investment capabilities will become the industry norm.
Growth of Innovative Financing: Tools like Medical Margin Loans will provide new avenues for managing health expenses.
Focus on Longevity: Platforms will increasingly support users in planning for longer, healthier lives.

Our Vision at HealthyWealth
We believe that the next generation of HSAs should empower individuals to take control of their health and financial futures without compromise. By merging traditional spending functionalities with advanced investment options and innovative financing tools, we aim to redefine what an HSA can be.

Our commitment is to create a platform that not only meets the immediate needs of our users but also supports their long-term aspirations for health and longevity. We see HSAs as more than just accounts—they are instruments for building a foundation for a healthier, wealthier future.

The HSA market is undergoing a significant transformation driven by digital innovation, demographic shifts, and changing consumer preferences. The emergence of integrated platforms like HealthyWealth represents a fundamental shift in how individuals manage their health finances.

Providers, employers, and account holders who embrace this integrated approach will be better positioned to thrive in a rapidly evolving market. By focusing on comprehensive solutions that address both spending and investment needs, we can collectively work toward a future where health and wealth are seamlessly connected.

Subscribe to the HSA Intelligence newsletter here

---

*Sources: Devenir HSA Research Report, Google Trends, Reddit analysis, industry studies, and demographic research. Projections include combined effects of market growth and platform preference shifts.*